Engineering Notes by Oriental Motor

Gearhead Selection for Stepper Motors

[fa icon="calendar"] Originally posted on Jul 25, 2024 6:06:42 PM
Last updated on August 23, 2024 / by Johann Tang

Johann Tang

Gearhead Selection for Stepper Motors
15:52

Selecting a gearhead for a stepper motor is like picking out the right shoes for the occasion. Sure, you can wear Air Jordans on a football field, but they're not better than a pair of regular cleats. Similarly, you can use a harmonic gearhead to drive a unidirectional conveyor, but you may be overpaying for its zero-backlash capability when you don't have to.  Picking the right gearhead can ensure the best balance between performance and budget.

In this article, I'll cover the types of gearheads offered for stepper motors and how to select one.

 

Topics covered:

  • Why Use a Gearhead?
  • Stepper Motor Sizing Example - Ball Screw Drive
  • About the αSTEP AZ Series
  • Types of Gearheads Offered for Stepper Motors
  • Summary

 

First, we'll dive into the reasons why gearheads are used.

 

Why use a gearhead?
 
A gearhead is similar to a belt-and-pulley mechanism, where one pulley runs slower than the other due to the difference in the two pulley diameters, a gearhead's output shaft runs slower than the motor pinion shaft by the factor of its gear ratio. The advantage is that the gearhead is more rigid and can house a series of gears in a much smaller footprint than a belt-and-pulley mechanism. 
 
  • A gearhead multiplies the motor's output torque by its gear ratio.  With more torque, a motor can either move the same load quicker or move more load. 

  • A gearhead also increases the axial and radial load specification since it increases the rigidity of the gear motor assembly. 

  • A right-angle gearhead can change the orientation of the output shaft so it can fit into tighter spaces.
A robot arm with a right-angle gear motor

For other advantages of geared motors, please read this article.

 

How does a gearhead work?
 
A gearhead's case houses a series of gears of different sizes. When a smaller pulley is used to drive a bigger pulley, the torque increases while the speed decreases due to the ratio between the pulley diameters. Gearhead transmission efficiency is also part of the formula since a bit of efficiency is lost when transmitting torque through gears.
 
The torque at the gearhead output shaft is the motor torque multiplied by the gear ratio and gear efficiency:
 

Permissible Torque

TG = TM × i × η​​
T.G.​ = Gearhead Permissible Torque
T M = Motor torque
i = Gearhead reduction ratio
η = Gearhead transmission efficiency

 

The gearhead output shaft speed is the motor output shaft speed divided by the gear ratio.

 

Gearhead Output Shaft Speed Calculation

 

Typically, the combined specifications for the gearmotor are already listed by the manufacturer, so all you have to do is verify the numbers.  However, if you purchased a motor and a gearhead from different manufacturers, then you'll have to do some calculations to determine the final output.

 
How is Gear Ratio Determined?

Determining the proper gear ratio requires knowing the torque, load inertia, and speed requirements for the specific application, so motor sizing calculations must be done first.  

After performing motor sizing calculations, select a motor and a gearhead (gear motor) that satisfy the required torque, total load inertia, and speed (RPM). Remember to add a safety factor.

 
Stepper Motor Sizing Example - Ball Screw Drive
 
There are many formulas to calculate the required torque.  The trick is knowing which one to apply.  For a stepper motor driving a ball screw, here's the formula used to calculate the required load torque.  First, figure out the "F" force (2), then plug it into the TL (load torque) formula (1).
 
Ball screw motor sizing example - gather variables Ball screw drive - load torque formula
 
Next, figure out the total load inertia by adding up all the load inertia values driven by the motor.  This definitely includes the linear moving load plus all the other rotating components, such as external pulley ratios.  Unless the load is very light, most of the load inertia should be the object in linear motion.

Formula to calculate inertia of load in linear motion

Inertia of a cylinder

 

Now, add up all load inertia values of objects driven by the motor to calculate the acceleration torque.  Acceleration torque is used only during the acceleration or deceleration portions of the motion profile. When the acceleration/deceleration time is shorter, this value can be larger than the load torque. Make sure you add the acceleration torque to the load torque for the total required torque. A load inertia and a rotor inertia value are necessary for calculating acceleration torque.
 
Motor sizing example - acceleration torque formula
 
Once completed, determine your total required torque by adding your required acceleration torque to your required load torque and then adding an adequate safety factor.  Make sure the total required torque is under the permissible torque specification of the motor + gearhead.  Also, confirm if the required RPM is within the specifications of the motor + gearhead.
 
 
FYI Don't forget about inertia ratios!

An open-loop stepper motor can drive from 5x to 10x its rotor inertia while a closed-loop stepper motor from the αSTEP (AlphaSTEP) product family can drive up to 30x.

When the inertia ratio exceeds the values in the table, a gearhead is recommended.

 
 
First, pick a type of gearhead that meets the required backlash or mounting preference. Then, select a gear ratio that meets the torque and RPM requirements. Also, check if the inertia ratio is within the maximum reference values and if the gearhead can handle the axial and radial loads.
  
 
For more information about motor sizing calculations and formulas, please refer to our motor sizing notes series.
 
 
FYI When to use planetary or harmonic gearheads?
For high precision motion control applications where the motor is operating in both CW and CCW directions, gear backlash can cause missed steps.  If backlash is a problem for the application, make sure to choose either a harmonic gearhead (no backlash) or a planetary gearhead (very low backlash).

 

About the αSTEP AZ Series

The αSTEP (AlphaSTEP) AZ Series is part of the αSTEP AZ Series product family that offers the most gearhead options.  The AZ Series is a closed-loop stepper motor and a universal driver system that combines the simplicity of open-loop stepper motors with the intelligence of servo systems.  The AZ Series offers unparalleled accuracy, reliability, and ease of use. This innovative technology utilizes a self-correcting hybrid control algorithm, low-loss laminations, and a battery-free mechanical absolute encoder, eliminating the need for time-consuming homing routines and ensuring position retention even during power outages.

 

Types of Gearheads Offered for the αSTEP AZ Series Motors

The AZ Series motor can be equipped with various types of gearheads, from spur to planetary to harmonic, allowing it to meet different application requirements.  As we will mention later, the AZ Series motors can also be equipped with ball screws and guides and be assembled as various types of linear actuators.

In this article, we'll explore the many types of gearheads that can be used with the AZ Series motors and understand how to select them properly.  We split the lineup into 2 categories: Oriental Motor original gearheads and 3rd party.

 
👍 Oriental Motor Gearheads / Gear Motors:
TS Type Up to 220 lb-in (25 Nm) | 10,000 hours rated life 

Taper Hobbed Geared Stepper Motors

TS gear - spur

A TS type gearhead is an updated version of the TH type gearhead and contains spur gears that are manufactured with high precision.  The output shaft gear undergoes high precision finishing after heat treatment to eliminate the impact of dimensional change caused by heat.  This allows TS gears to have a simple structure with low backlash that does not require any special adjustment mechanism, such as a tapered gears.

The TS type gearhead offers higher permissible torque, maximum torque, and maximum RPM than other taper-hobbed gearheads.

 

Availability: AZ Series, RK II Series

Frame sizes: 42, 60, and 90 mm 

Gear ratios: 3.6:1 to 30:1

Max torque: 220 lb-in (25 Nm)

Backlash: 10 arc min (0.17°)

CS Type Up to 39 lb-in (4.4 Nm) | 10,000 hours rated life

geared stepper motors

 

Centered Shaft

The CS type gearhead is a unique spur gearhead where the output shaft is centered instead of offset (like the TS type).  The design adds a protrusion on the gearhead case in order to place the final stage gear and output shaft on the same axis as the pinion shaft.  With the extra space, bigger gears and bearings can be used to transmit more torque and handle more load.

The CS type gearhead has approximately double the torque, as well as 2.6 times the axial load and 4 times the radial load when compared to other spur gearheads, such as the SH type.

 

Availability: PKP Series

Frame sizes: 28, 42, and 60 mm 

Gear ratios: 5:1 to 20:1

Max torque: 39 lb-in (4.4 Nm)

Backlash: 45 arc min (0.75°)

FC Type Up to 92 lb-in (10.4 Nm) | 10,000 hours rated life

Right-Angle Geared Stepper Motor

Right-angle FC Gear

An FC type gearhead is a compact right-angle gearhead made up of a high strength disc-shaped gear (face gear) meshing with a traditional spur gear. With the FC type, high precision, high strength and space savings are possible with lower backlash than other spur gears.

This is a unique gear motor that can minimize footprint for conveyors or robotics by reducing the motor overhang length.  The FC type gear motors are offered in either "Up" or "Down" versions to indicate the cable location.

 

Availability: AZ Series, RKII Series

Frame sizes: 42, and 60 mm 

Gear ratios: 7.2:1 to 30:1

Max torque: 92 lb-in (10.4 Nm)

Backlash: 10 arc min (0.17°)

PS Type Up to 320 lb-in (36 Nm) | 20,000 hours rated life

Planetary Gear Stepper Motors

Planetary Gear Structure

 

 

A PS type gearhead's structure primarily consists of a sun gear in the center, planetary gears around it, and an internal tooth gear on the outside.  As the sun gear rotates, the planetary gears rotate around it.  The movement of the planetary gears determine the rotation of the output shaft via the carrier.

The planetary gear design distributes torque to many gears, which allows for higher torque output than a spur gear design. The PS type gearhead also uses a high accuracy gear design, which reduces backlash more than a spur gear design but still more than a harmonic gearhead.

 

Availability: AZ Series, RKII Series

Frame sizes: 28, 42, 60, and 90 mm 

Gear ratios: 5:1 to 50:1

Max torque: 320 lb-in (36Nm)

Backlash: 9 arc min (0.15°)

 

👍 Neugart, Harmonic Drive Gearheads / Gear Motors:

PLE Type Up to 974 lb-in (110 Nm)

AZ Series motor with a PLE gearhead

Inside a PLE gearhead

The PLE Series gearhead* employs an efficient planetary gear mechanism and is composed of fully hardened gears. Sun gear and planetary gears are honed (precision final machining after heat treatment). This technology guarantees extremely high torque density, long life, and low backlash.

Different than our other pre-assembled gear motors,  the PLE type gearhead and motor are shipped separately and must be assembled using the included gasket and screws.

 

Availability: AZ Series, RKII Series

Frame sizes: 42, 60, and 90 mm 

Gear ratios: 5:1 to 40:1

Max torque: 974 lb-in (110 Nm)

Backlash: 9 arc min (0.15°)

HPG Type (Shaft or Flange Types) Up to 210 lb-in (24 Nm)

HPG geared stepper motor with shaftHPG geared stepper motor with flange

The HPG planetary/harmonic gearhead is a hybrid version that combines technologies of the planetary and harmonic gears.  It applies the thin elastic gear from harmonic gear technology to the internal gear of the planetary gearhead to achieve low backlash. 

The HPG gear features high positioning accuracy, high permissible torque, and high maximum instantaneous torque.  The HPG Gears are available with a center shaft or surface mount to meet the needs of various applications.

 

Availability: AZ Series, RKII Series

Frame sizes: 42, 60, and 90 mm 

Gear ratios: 5:1 to 15:1

Max torque: 210 lb-in (24 Nm)

Backlash: 3 arc min (0.05°)

HS Type Up to 460 lb-in (52 Nm) | 10,000 hours rated life*

Harmonic Geared Stepper Motors

Harmonic Gear Cross SectionHarmonic Gear Structure

 

The HS type gearhead is a high-torque version of the HPG gearhead with no backlash.  This is a true harmonic gearhead that uses a circular spline, wave generator, and flex spline. 

With a large number of teeth that mesh at the same time in the flex spline, the effects of tooth pitch error and cumulative pitch error on rotational accuracy are averaged out, resulting in high positioning accuracy.  High gear ratios are available for high torque generation.

Due to its high accuracy, non-backlash, and high-performance gear design, the mechanical life, permissible torque, and maximum torque are vastly improved.  The rate life has been increased from 5,000 hours (conventional model) to 10,000 hours, except for the 1.65" (42 mm) frame size.

 

Availability: AZ Series, RKII Series

Frame sizes: 30, 42, 60, and 90 mm 

Gear ratios: 50:1 to 100:1

Max torque: 460 lb-in (52Nm)

Backlash: none

 
For higher loads, the αSTEP AZ Series product family offers hollow rotary actuators.  The product family can even cover linear motion requirements with linear slides, linear cylinders, rack and pinion actuators, compact actuators, and compact grippers.
 

Summary

The article discusses the importance of selecting the right gearhead and gear ratio for motors used in high-precision motion control applications. It explains how gearheads increase output torque and decrease speed and covers various types of gearheads available for the αSTEP AZ Series motors. 

Selecting the appropriate gearhead is crucial for maximizing the performance of AZ Series motors. The right choice depends on factors such as:

  1. Required torque and speed (the basics)
  2. Precision needs (backlash considerations)
  3. Space constraints (parallel shaft or right-angle)
  4. Load characteristics (inertia, axial and radial loads)
  5. Environmental conditions (IP rating requirements)
  6. Budget constraints  (features vs cost)

Sometimes, you can't have everything you want, so it's important to separate the must-haves from the nice-to-haves that might not be necessary for the application.

The αSTEP AZ Series offers a diverse range of gearhead options, each with its unique advantages:

  • TS Type: High-precision spur gears with low backlash, suitable for general applications.
  • FC Type: Compact right-angle gearhead, ideal for space-constrained designs.
  • PS Type: Planetary gears offering higher torque and lower backlash than spur gears.
  • PLE Type: High torque density and long life, with optimized planetary gear mechanism.
  • HPG Type: Combines harmonic and planetary gears for high accuracy and torque.
  • HS Type: High torque harmonic gears with zero backlash for the highest precision needs.

By using modular motors and linear actuators from the αSTEP AZ Series product family, machine builders can easily build multiple motion axes within the same machine. The universal programmable drivers can operate with both motors and linear actuators, simplifying machine design, reducing learning curves, and cutting down on the bill of materials.

Whether for packaging machinery, semiconductor equipment, medical devices, or various robots, the αSTEP AZ Series product family provides versatile solutions that enhance reliability and productivity while reducing energy consumption and maintenance needs.

 

αSTEP AlphaSTEP hybrid step-servo

AlphaSTEP AZ Series product family

 

Too busy to figure out which gearhead to use, or what gear ratio to select?  Our team is ready to help you size the perfect motor.

 

Topics: Stepper Motors, Alphastep Hybrid Control, Motor Sizing, Gearheads, Motion Control Basics

Johann Tang

Written by Johann Tang

Johann Tang is a Product Specialist at Oriental Motor USA Corp. Before joining the marketing team, he spent 15 years in sales, technical application support, and training of various types of fractional horsepower electric motors, gear motors, actuators, drivers, and controllers. If you have any questions, please feel free to use the live chat window, 1-800-GO-VEXTA (1-800-468-3982), or techsupport@orientalmotor.com, to reach our product support team. Johann can be reached via LinkedIn. Sorry, comments have been turned off.

    Subscribe Here!

    Recent Posts

    New call-to-action
    Product Guide